Stuffed Review: Jodie Comer and Harry Melling are Magical in Gothic Body Horror Musical

TIFF: In this morbid musical for fans of Sweeney Todd, Comer stars as an oddball who falls for the man she plans to turn into a human taxidermy (Melling)

by Alex Kaan 16 September 2026

BFI

In 2001, Armin Meiwes, the so-called Rotenburg Cannibal, killed and ate a 43-year-old engineer named Bernd Brandes. The catch? He did so with his victim’s filmed consent after Brandes responded enthusiastically to an internet advertisement seeking a young man for “slaughter and consumption”. Inspired by the true crime, writer-director Theo Rhys (with his feature debut) and co-writer and composer Joss Holden-Rea have crafted a story that looks past the horrific murder of it all and reframes the incident as only a few might see it: a fated love story between two people who somehow found the perfect (and only) partner for them.

Reviving the macabre horror comedy and rich visuals of a vintage Tim Burton film, Stuffed turns a musical about a taxidermist falling in love with her human subject into a dazzling Gothic rom-com elevated by the irresistible pairing of Jodie Comer and Harry Melling. Unfolding in a nightmarish, timeless vision of a dreary English town, the film follows Araminta (Comer), a brooding animal-stuffer known to locals as the “Munchenbridge Muncher” because of the street she lives on and a cruel cannibalistic rumour. Bernie, meanwhile, is a meek sandwich factory worker who is haunted by the idea of being forgotten, a feeling exacerbated by his mother’s (Claire Novelli) dementia and his colleagues’ utter disinterest in him despite his 10 years of employment.

BFI

Sitting across their boxy old computers, the pair are united via a chatroom after Araminta posts a classified ad as she tries to fulfil her dream: finding a man to turn into a piece of human taxidermy. With Bernie asking existential questions like “When my body dies / Will I truly disappear?” via song, the notion of becoming “the first person to live forever” suddenly becomes rather attractive, and he agrees to become Araminta’s masterwork. While the film’s set pieces are charmingly eccentric and unpredictable, you can identify the driving dramatic tension from a mile away. As Araminta and Bernie grow closer while planning the titular stuffing — cue a delightful shopping montage for Bernie’s funereal attire — the novel experience of intimacy and companionship begins to sow seeds of doubt about whether they should go through with the mission.

With fans of fellow dark romance Lisa Frankenstein sure to lap it up, Stuffed feels like it was engineered in a dimly lit lab on a stormy night for a particular breed of morbid viewer. This is bound to become a cult film, with the aesthetics alone enough to charm midnight crowds. Rhys and Holden-Rea conjure up an intoxicating atmosphere through the pairing of the surreal worldbuilding with a dark, rich orchestration reminiscent of Bernard Herrmann’s Hitchcock scores.

BFI

Yet the visual and sonic extravagance is only half the puzzle piece, or even less. As a rom-com, the film hinges entirely on the two leads and their chemistry — and thankfully they deliver. A worthy successor to Helena Bonham Carter’s Mrs Lovett, Jodie Comer is mesmerising as a gloomy misfit taxidermist, with a performance that remains deeply affecting even as she’s belting out Sweeney Todd-esque numbers while skinning furry creatures. Melling matches that quality in a performance that amusingly plays as a companion piece to his doe-eyed submissive in BDSM romance Pillion, another rom-com about alternative intimacy, and his skill at playing dynamic mild-mannered characters is proving unrivalled.

Gory, tender, and utterly charming, Stuffed is a stellar genre-bending musical driven by two pitch-perfect leads.

Previous
Previous

Our Most Anticipated Horror Movies at Fantastic Fest 2026

Next
Next

'Widow’s Bay' Breaks Record for Most Emmys for a Comedy Series in a Single Season with 14 Wins